Don’t Be a Turkey

Back when I worked in banking, there were a lot of mergers. One year, in September, our bank was bought by another, larger organization.

Everything was fine until Thanksgiving. In our original company, on the Friday before Thanksgiving, the company would bring each employee a big, frozen turkey.

But after the merger, there were no turkeys. And people were angry. Employees were saying, “Man, these people don’t care about customers, they don’t care about Thanksgiving and they obviously don’t care about me!” All because there were no turkeys.

The bank, realizing that they had just messed things up, arranged for a local grocery store to honor a coupon for $15 off a turkey. They distributed the coupons on Monday.

That made things even worse. Employees said, “Not only do they not care, but they are so crass as to think all we’re worth is a coupon!”

This was company culture at work. The original bank had a culture of caring about employees that was expressed through the turkeys. Company culture can often be found as artifacts: values (like caring about customers and employees), assumptions, narratives, heroes, symbols (like dress code, logos and mottos) and rituals (like promotions, celebrations, company picnics, or in this case, Thanksgiving turkeys).

Those turkeys showed that the company cared. Without knowing it, the new bank had eliminated a ritual of employee appreciation, confirming (unfounded) fears that the new bank’s culture was heartless and uncaring.

Culture Already Exists

Every company has a culture, a remnant of all the relationships and actions of a team or organization. Culture shows up in the unwritten rules that guide behavior when the boss isn’t around. Because it’s so powerful, managers or leaders may want to direct it. But writing it down or communicating it directly makes it “policy,” not culture. So how can you influence it?

Define Your Culture

When you try to change culture, you first have to know what your existing culture is. Culture is evident from the ways people act. For example, does an employee have authority to “make things right” by a customer? Can they do it to a certain dollar limit? Do they have to check with someone first? It’s hard to write a policy that says, “Do what makes sense.” Culture can be a more powerful guide than policy. Asking your team what they think or how they would handle a situation can tell you a lot about the culture.

After observing your culture, you can decide what you’d like the new culture to be. Once you decide on the new culture that you want, you can’t just write it down in a memo and pass it out to your employees. (“The culture has changed! Here’s what it is!”) In order to change culture, you have to think about human behavior and think carefully about how to migrate to the new culture.

In the 1940s, Kurt Lewin suggested three stages for creating intentional change: unfreeze, change and refreeze. You “unfreeze,” to let employees know that things are not always the same, you change things, and then you refreeze with the new culture.

Unfreeze

Sometimes, you need to create intentional disruption in order to change your culture. That lets employees know that it’s not the way it used to be. In the turkey example, the disruption wasn’t intentional. The new company could have managed the process better by letting employees know that there weren’t going to be turkeys delivered on the Friday before Thanksgiving.

Change

Following this example, the company might have explained that they show appreciation at their summer awards picnic. Or they might have pointed out that their culture rewards cost savings rather than expressing employee appreciation with turkeys.

Refreeze

Refreezing the culture requires creating new artifacts. So, what new traditions would reflect the desired culture? Could you celebrate a hero who saved the company a lot of money? Look for opportunities—patterns of the new culture—and really bring those to light, while recognizing that the old patterns are still important. Maybe an intentional effort by senior leaders to visit each member of the team and express gratitude personally would be a way to show that the company can appreciate employees without spending money. The leaders’ behavior influences culture far more than words.

Ultimately, culture is determined by the team, not the leader, but leaders can influence culture through their actions – no turkeys needed.

This article originally appeared in Agri-Marketing Magazine.

 

RELATED POSTS:

Leading During Times of Fear and Uncertainty

It has been said that the only thing constant is change. If that’s so, then it’s equally true that there are times when fear greases the bearings in the wheels of change. While fear turned inward will result in paralyzing inaction, fear turned outward can serve as a catalyst for inspiration and innovation. Theories that encourage “courageous leadership” and “leading fearlessly” focus on behaviors that attempt to conquer fear. A more effective, pragmatic response would be for leaders to understand how to acknowledge fear and lead effectively during times of uncertainty.

No Points for Original Thought: All That Matters Is Execution

In the mid 1990’s, I had the honor of leading the operations and technology teams at American Express in the development and introduction of a remarkably successful credit card. Amex invested nearly 18 months in researching and designing compelling features for the new card. Some of the new features were so distinct in comparison to credit cards already in the market, the technology and operations teams had a real chore enhancing our current systems and procedures to support the new design. But with a great deal of effort, the new card was launched and the response from customers was amazing, generating one of the most successful product offerings in Amex’s history.

Rethink Your Business for the Digital Age

In The Digital Transformation Playbook: Rethink Your Business for the Digital Age, David Rogers identifies five domains of digital transformation for an existing company. The figure below identifies those five domains as customers, competition, data, innovation and value.